Bah Humbug

Dec 4, 2013

I love Christmas. It is by far my favorite holiday. I love the whole month of anticipation and activities leading up to it; I love the Christmas carols and songs; I love the transformation of the dark and dismal streets into elegant splendor. And I love focusing on the incomprehensible love and sacrifice of the Savior.

But I don't love everything about the Season. At the risk of offending the majority of my readers, here are five things I fervently wish would go (and stay) away:

1. Elf on the Shelf. I know this is supposedly a revived tradition from the 1950's, but it seems more like a commercialized scheme to me. Honestly, I think if this was someone's personal family tradition, I might think it was kind of cute and creative, but where everyone has their own little elf to keep an eye on them during the day and then wreak havoc at night, it's just so ridiculous for so many reasons: 1) I know the elf doesn't have to do naughty things, but many of them do (that seems to kind of be the point), and that just seems like a horrible message for my kids (you better watch out, you better not cry, but let's all laugh about Bobby the Elf spilling soda pop all over the floor and making snow angels in rice). 2) It feels so fake to me. Even if I was a fan, I don't think I could pull off the nightly deceptions. (What about Santa, you ask? That's a whole other discussion, but even though Santa comes to our house, I try to focus more on other things. Still, I know I'm a bit of a hypocrite on this point.) 3) It's one more daily thing to clutter my life. We do have lots of holiday traditions (some of them daily), but I try to only hang onto ones that I feel strongly about and enjoy doing every year. So if you do Elf on the Shelf, I hope it's filling your life with joy and happiness. (I found this article on the Nauvoo Times to be very validating.) I had a feeling Aaron would probably be hearing about elves on shelves from kids at school, and so before he even asked about it, I flat out told him there was no way we'd ever get one. Just call me Scrooge.

2. Inflatable decorations. You know what I'm talking about, right? Giant Santa Clauses and Grinches and Snoopys that blow up like balloons and fill up your entire front yard. They look so tacky and cheap to me, and it seems like the lazy man's way of decorating: instead of stringing lights around your trees, why not stick a giant purple hippo wearing a Santa Claus hat on your front porch (you think I'm kidding . . . I drove past this very thing today) and call it good?

3. Jingle Bell Rock, etc. I'm as much a fan of fun Christmas songs as the next person. I like Jingle Bells and Frosty and Have a Holly Jolly Christmas. But I am not a fan of poorly composed Christmas songs with stupid lyrics performed by some obnoxious singer on a synthesizer. I'd rather drink a gallon of eggnog (see #5). 

4. Santa Claus' new persona. Instead of being a figure of generosity, kindness, and goodwill, there are so many movies, books, songs, decorations, and commercials that paint Santa as a big, fat, bumbling idiot. Santa Claus with sunglasses and polka-dotted shorts playing a saxophone? Why would I want to believe in someone like that? That is not the Santa I grew up believing in, and if that's the image my boys are creating from the superficial commercialization they see everywhere, then I guess we won't be believing in Santa Claus for much longer.

5. Eggnog. I used to drink it because my family had special Christmas mugs to sip it from, but it's foul stuff, and I'm done with it.

Whew, that felt good, but do I have any friends left? Does anyone else agree with me? What are the things that make you say "Bah humbug"?

31 comments:

  1. I totally agree with most of that. What is with every store trying shove Elf on the Shelf at us? It's weird and little creepy that this elf is just staring at you. As for eggnog, I rarely drink it so I haven't really formed an opinion (though maybe that's a sign that I'm not a fan).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I thought about mentioning the creepiness factor as well, but I'd already ranted long enough. :-)

      Delete
  2. All I can say is amen to everything that you said about the Elf on the shelf. I mean seriously people?!? We showed up at playgroup today and all of the kids were talking about their elves and what they did. Poor Isaac had no idea what they were talking about. It is so prevalent that we (who don't choose to have that tradition) are the anomaly (or so it feels) - but then again we don't "do" Santa Claus at my house either - so we should be used to being the weirdos. :) On top of everything that you shared - I struggle that it feels like yet another new and lofty expectation placed on mothers during this busy season. Because of course we are supposed to be somehow making dazzling neighbor gifts, glitzy Christmas cards, decorating our homes, making lunch for our kids in the shapes of christmas trees and candy canes, doing 20 different advent activities a day, baking homemade goodies, crafting up the wazoo, etc... So I say it again - seriously people?!?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh, Kendra, you crack me up, but I totally agree with you.

      Delete
  3. I'm still your friend, but ONLY because I agree with you. Who knows? You may have lost our friendship at #6. :) haha I agree with Kendra too. There's this expectation level for moms during this time of year. I am flooded with great ideas. While at a stop light today, I eliminated one of those good ideas for this year, save it for next...and then decided to scrap it all and just relax and enjoy the season.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've debated scrapping everything this year as well. I'm just feeling such a need to simplify!

      Delete
  4. I worked at a certain big box book store when Elf on the Shelf was launched. They made me do an Elf storytime. I cannot stand the Elf. Nope. I like Santa, I like egg nog, I don't mind inflatables (although the wind can blow so hard here, they aren't necessarily the best idea), and although I really wish the Christmas music station would shake things up, I still listen to it. But the ELF. Ugh. And it's so expensive!!!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with you on every point but the egg nog; however, I do not know what an elf on the shelf is.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I agree with you on every point but the egg nog; however, I do not know what an elf on the shelf is.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I agree with you on every point but the egg nog; however, I do not know what an elf on the shelf is.

    ReplyDelete
  8. My grandparents had the elf on the shelf and put it up every single year so out of nostalgia I bought Christopher pop in kins. (he's much less creepy) I don't plan to use him til next year, and just move him around because I like treasure hunts. I found him used too so it was super cheap- I would never have paid full price and done all the elaborate things with him. Also last year I would have wholeheartedly agreed with the inflatables, but this year as I've spent tons of time with Tyler watching 'cuckoos' (any one that has something that pops up or down) they're starting to grow on me. I wouldn't ever get one for myself, but I don't mind the joy he gets from other people's inflatables :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I can see your point with the inflatables. My kids definitely are drawn to them, so I guess I should like them for their sakes, but I just can't seem to.

      Delete
  9. I'm totally with you on #1, #2, and #4. I don't mind #3 enough to get worked up over it - I just don't pay attention to the songs I don't like, or I get a good laugh out of them. As for eggnog, I don't drink it so I have no thoughts :) But Elf On A Shelf - I'm sorry, that's just creepy and weird! And Inflatable lawn ornaments are flat out tacky! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I guess I'm kind of the same way with the cheesy Christmas songs . . . they bug me but I also enjoy making fun of them. :-)

      Delete
  10. I agree with all of your points! Especially that elf. It's a manipulation tool to get kids to be good :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. Oh my, I'm so with you! If there's any reason at all why I'm glad to not have kids right now it's that I don't have to do Elf on the Shelf. I seriously hate it that much.

    I can never remember whether it's Jingle Bell Rock or Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree that is my second least favorite Christmas song (which basically means I don't like either of them) but the all time worst Christmas song out there is Santa Baby.

    I'm also not at all a fan of egg nog.

    Now I want to do a post like this, except I'd probably just repeat all of the things you've written!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Santa Baby! Last night as I was writing this post, I was racking my brain trying to remember the Christmas song that I REALLY hate. That was the one!

      Delete
  12. I agree with everything you said! Except eggnog. I can't drink it but I love the stuff!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Since you like eggnog, I'm sorry you can't drink it! That's a bummer.

      Delete
  13. I love this list! Last night my kids asked why we don't have a elf. They saw the movie (!) and book at their grandparents house. I'm glad I'm not he only one who dislikes it. As for songs, I really can't stand the Mr. Grinch song.
    As for the inflatables, I don't like them, but my kids love them! You should drive down our street. Our neighbors have Santa on a motorcycle. It'll meet two of your pet peeves at once!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Happy to hear someone else admit that eggnog is not good! Now, how about fruitcake?

    ReplyDelete
  15. I'm with you on 1, 2, 4, and 5, Amy. Am ok with the music :-) Oh, and fruitcake makes me positively shudder.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Amen to all five. And I have dear friends and family who heartily disagree with me, but I am very strongly opposed to decorating for Christmas before it has even been Thanksgiving! I used to think the day after was early, and now people are doing it even sooner! We don't get our tree until the second Saturday of December, usually, and then we get down the decorations and do the house over the next few days as we have time. I do love having it up, so it stays past New Year's. And that is how I love it and it is calm and peaceful and celebratory to me.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I am with you on all of these... except for the eggnog. I really like eggnog - but the real stuff, not that gross stuff in the supermarket.

    ReplyDelete
  18. What exactly do you mean by "foul stuff"? I do love me some eggnog-although I was a little disheartened tonight when I read the ingredient list: high fructose corn syrup AND corn syrup AND sugar AND (this has always sounded so gross to me:) corn syrup solids? Are all 4 of those things really truly necessary? I need to find that "real stuff" Erica mentioned. Yum.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I hadn't even heard of Elf on the Shelf until last year, when a lady I visit teach was raving about how she was coming up with these crazy pranks for the elf to do. I thought it was weird at the time, and now that I've heard a few other people talk about it, I am sure I never want to have one in my home.

    However, that article really bothered me. I agreed with her points about the elf and that it puts the focus on the materialistic, selfish side of Christmas, but I thought the article was incredibly preachy and self-righteous. I don't think there's anything wrong with having secular traditions in your home for Christmas, like Santa Claus or an elf that teaches kids to be good at Christmas time. Sometimes all kids want is to have what every other kid has — and while I don't think the Elf on the Shelf fits into this category, I plan to teach my kids about giving thoughtful gifts as well, at Christmastime and every other time of the year.

    This line bothered me the most: "if any child I love informs me that they are being watched by an elf when they sleep, I will arm them with pepper spray and a rape whistle. That’s just common sense." Comparing a harmless Christmas tradition to a stalker is ridiculous and judgmental, and it made my blood boil.

    Anyway. I agree with you (the inflatable stuff is SO gross and I am really picky about Christmas music), and thanks for letting me vent.

    ReplyDelete
  20. 1. The Elf on Our Shelf does not do weird, harmful, destructive things that make more work for the mother. He just moves around to a new location each night. He doesn't fill my life with joy and happiness, but everyone seems to have fun trying to find him each morning, kind of like a treasure hunt.

    2. I'm ambivalent about inflatables. I like snow globes and penguins, but others are not very endearing. And I don't really like seeing them deflated on the ground during the day, which they are many times.

    3. This year I learned Jingle Bell Rock on the ukulele (that's probably going to be even worse for you than just hearing a recorded version by a professional entertainer). So I will probably keep it to myself while you are home and try to avoid family contention.

    4. I am rather unaware of Santa's new persona. He seems to me to be the same jolly old elf as always. I guess I don't get around much anymore or watch any new shows.

    5. Eggnog is not foul, but about two sips per year is enough for me. I'll take a root beer float instead.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I don't like the inflatable decorations, either...but homemade eggnog (using low fat milk) is pretty good!

    ReplyDelete

Proudly designed by Mlekoshi playground