The Unrest-Cure and Other Stories by Saki

Nov 16, 2015

When I made the goal at the beginning of the year to "read a short stories collection," I had no idea what kind of headache I was signing up for. I didn't have a particular collection in mind, but I figured there must be a list out there somewhere of "popular short stories collections everyone must read to be a real reader." I would just pick one off the list, read it, and be done with it.

Eleven months later, and after trying at least a half dozen collections, I can tell you, it wasn't as simple as that. I tried Amy Bloom, Anthony Doerr, Alice Munroe, and Jhumpa Lahiri, but abandoned all of them after just a few pages because of their common thread of infidelity. Seriously, I was not interested in reading a collection of a dozen stories about infidelity, no matter how well-written or thought-provoking they were .

I began to wonder if it was possible to write a short story without infidelity or if that was a qualification for getting published. I had two other options: a thick volume of Jack London stories that would have taken me the rest of the year to finish or Just So Stories by Rudyard Kipling (which I read to the boys over the summer). The obvious choice should have been to just count Just So Stories since I could check it off right then and there and move on with my life.

But this is where you're going to see my Upholder Tendency coming through loud and clear. When I read Just So Stories to the boys, I intended to use it to fulfill my "read a children's classic" goal. In fact, I never gave a thought to it being a collection of short stories (even though, of course, that's exactly what it is). Additionally, when I made the goal to read a short stories collections, my intent was to get a feel for what the genre was like and read a popular, well-known collection. Even though I was the one making the rules, I didn't want to fall back on Just So Stories because it was the "easy" choice.

But after trying five other collections, I was about to do just that. I was definitely getting a feel for the genre, and I was beginning to think I was not cut out for short stories.

And then, someone, somewhere referenced Saki and The Unrest-Cure. I wish I could remember how I found out about it because I would love to personally thank whoever it was. I loved these stories, and, as it turned out, they were exactly what I was looking for all along.

Saki is the pen name of Hector Hugh Munro. He was born in 1870 and lived for most of his life in England before being killed during WWI. I'd never heard of Saki before picking up this book, but he was actually somewhat of an authority on the short story. Without meaning to, really just out of desperation, I picked up the kind of collection I had been wanting.

This particular collection is comprised of stories from five previously published collections. I liked getting a broad view of Saki's style. If I had to use three words to describe him, witty, sardonic, and morbid would all come to mind. I am not all that familiar with British humor, but several of Mike's family members are, and I have a feeling they would love these stories (if they haven't already discovered them, which they probably have). I'm guessing he would seem similar to P.G. Wodehouse, although that's an author I have yet to read.

Anyway, these stories were short, funny, and almost always involved some unexpected twist at the end.

For example, one of my favorite stories (and I guess one of his most popular ones) was "The Open Window." In it, Mr. Framton Nuttel has come to call on Mrs. Sappleton. He has just moved into the neighborhood and is seeking to become acquainted with his neighbors. Mrs. Sappleton's niece answers the door and entertains him while they are waiting. She confides to Mr. Nuttel that the drawing room window is open because her aunt is waiting for her husband to come home . . . he disappeared three years ago. She paints this sad and vivid and actually quite horrifying picture of her slightly insane aunt. Mr. Nuttel feels quite sorry about the whole situation, but his sympathy turns to terror when the aunt enters the drawing room and says, "Here they are at last! Just in time for tea." Mr. Nuttel can see three figures walking towards the open window, but he doesn't stick around to meet them. He bolts out the door, and the niece accounts for his strange behavior by coming up with an elaborate tale to match the one she just told him. The story ends, "Romance at short notice was her specialty."

All of them had that same slightly irreverent, sarcastic quality, and I really loved them. Here are a few other favorite lines:
  • This from Egbert to his wife, Lady Anne, whom he's trying to smooth over a quarrel with: "My remark at lunch had a purely academic application," he announced; "you seem to put an unnecessarily personal significance to it."
  • "Susan Mebberley was a charming woman, but she was also an aunt."
  • "My aunt never lunches," said Clovis; "she belongs to the National Anti-Luncheon League, which is doing quite a lot of good work in a quiet, unobtrusive way. A subscription of half a crown per quarter entitles you to go without ninety-two luncheons."
  • "The aunt of Mrs. Greyes declared afterwards that she found herself subconsciously repeating 'The Assyrian came down like a wolf on the fold' under her breath, and she was generally believed."
I will warn you that he doesn't mind killing off characters without the least warning or provocation. I was seriously afraid he was going to do just that in "The Penance," but thankfully, he didn't. That was one story I don't think I could have handled it in.

With 2016 just around the corner, I've been thinking about the reading goals I want to make for the year. "Read a short stories collection" will not be making the cut this time. However, if that's going to be one of your goals, I can save you a lot of time and trouble and decision: Just read this one. You're welcome.

I'd love to hear your own experiences with short stories in the comments. Did I abandon some of the other collections too quickly? Have you read anything by Saki before?

15 comments:

  1. I'm with you -- I find stories about infidelity to be tedious. Also, if characters start doing drugs (especially shooting up) I find it very hard to have sympathy. I haven't tried to read Wild or Trainspotting because I figure I'll be too annoyed to get anything out of them.

    I read a book of short stories by Margaret Atwood this year (Stone Mattress), and they were mostly about identity and writing. Also, some of them had characters in common, which I also find helps pull me along. If you find yourself forced to read another book of short stories for some unknown reason, you might try her.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's not that I have anything against short stories per se. I would be happy to read another collection if it was something that I liked, and Margaret Atwood sounds like a great choice. I might even read it of my own free will! ;-)

      Delete
  2. Oh, I listened to some Saki stories on audiobook last year and loved them. They are so perfectly British and witty, interesting and fun! I'm really glad you enjoyed them, too.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yep, totally! I bet they'd be fun to listen to!

      Delete
  3. I guess I don't really read many short stories as a separate genre much, more within a genre. For instance, I like the short story collections of L. M. Montgomery and Georgette Heyer. I have many fantasy collections that I have read and enjoyed. However I give myself permission to skip stories that do not interest me and mostly read my favorite authors. I have read Saki and think his humor is an acquired taste but pretty good.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I was actually this close to reading L.M. Montgomery's short stories, but again, that felt like cheating to me because it didn't seem like I would be stretching my reading muscles very much since I already know that I adore everything Montgomery writes. But I'm definitely going to read them in the future when I don't have some self-imposed rule I'm trying to adhere to. :-)

      Delete
  4. I also really like the L. M. Montgomery short stories. If you like fairy tale retellings, Vivian Vande Velde has some great short story collections. Her book "Cloaked in Red" was excellent, as was "The Rumplestiltskin Problem."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. These sound great! I wish I'd known about them earlier in the year. Next year . . . (for fun, not for a goal).

      Delete
  5. I loved Saki when I read him many many moons ago, but don't recall him being much like P. G. Wodehouse at all, except perhaps in the subtlety of their humor. But put Wodehouse on your must-read list! Two of my favorite short story authors are O. Henry and F. Scott Fitzgerald. And also Chesterton's Father Brown stories.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Good to know. I'll have to read P.G. Wodehouse so that I can make an actual comparison. :-) I love O. Henry as well. Since I'd already read a couple of his stories, I was trying to make myself branch out a little.

      Delete
  6. O'Henry has a collection of short stories. and Australian Henry Lawson has some short stories, though I find him a bit depressing.
    Looking forward to hearing your new reading goal

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've read a couple of O'Henry's stories, but I need to explore his work further. And thanks for the other recommendation, although I'll probably need to gear up for him if he's depressing. ;-)

      Delete
  7. That's how I feel about a lot of fiction--most of it contains elements I just don't want to get cozy with. I'm not familiar with Saki, but I plan to read a short story collection next year. I'm thinking I'll go with O. Henry. I've never read anything by him.

    I took a class on the short story in college and I remember we started out with Anton Chekhov, and I loved those stories. We also read James Joyce (I remember loving "The Dead"), Ernest Hemingway, and Lorrie Moore. I think I'd definitely enjoy classic short stories over contemporary ones for the subject matter.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think you'll love O. Henry. Thanks for the other suggestions!

      Delete
  8. Okay, where were all these AWESOME suggestions eleven months ago?! You guys are making me want to make this a goal again just because, with this list in hand, I think it would be a million times easier to find something I liked!

    ReplyDelete

Proudly designed by Mlekoshi playground